Papi Steak Miami Beach
Closed
Papi Steak Miami Beach
ClosedOpens 6:00 PM·$$$$·$100+ per person·Steakhouse
High-energy South of Fifth steakhouse where fine dining meets theatrical celebration
About Papi Steak Miami Beach
Highlights
Group Celebrations
Date Night
Instagram-Worthy
Signature Papi Steak Tomahawk
Signature The Beef Case
Live Entertainment
Private Events
Reservations Recommended
Dining Essentials
Dress Code
Upscale / Dressy — jacket preferred
Typical Visit
2-3 hours
Verified
8.0
/10Service
8.0
Ambience
9.0
Food Quality
8.0
Value for Money
5.0
Location
9.0
Score derived from 3,600+ public reviews
Scored on published criteria from real guest data. Ranks are never for sale. How we rank →
Closed Opens 6:00 PM
Monday6:00 PM – 11:00 PM
Tuesday6:00 PM – 10:00 PM
Wednesday6:00 PM – 10:00 PM
Thursday6:00 PM – 11:00 PM
Friday6:00 PM – 12:00 AM
Saturday6:00 PM – 12:00 AM
Sunday6:00 PM – 11:00 PM
The Experience
Category
Cuisine
Amenities
Live EntertainmentPrivate EventsReservations RecommendedLivelyWheelchair AccessibleTrendyWine ListUpscaleBottle ServiceCredit Cards AcceptedBeer SelectionPrivate Dining
Meals
Signature Dishes
View full menu →Papi Steak Tomahawk
32-ounce tomahawk steak served with the restaurant's proprietary secret sauce — the namesake dish and most iconic cut on the menu.
The Beef Case
55-ounce Australian Wagyu tomahawk presented tableside inside a rhinestone-encrusted briefcase — a theatrical showpiece and the restaurant's most talked-about experience.
Wagyu Pastrami
A fan-favorite appetizer featuring high-grade Wagyu beef prepared pastrami-style, frequently cited in reviews as a must-order starter.
Filet Mignon
8-ounce filet mignon, one of the most reviewed cuts on the menu and a perennial bestseller.
Truffle Corn
A popular side dish with a strong cult following among regular diners, frequently highlighted in TripAdvisor reviews.
Steak Tartare
Hand-cut prime tenderloin with black garlic dijonnaise, smoked paprika aioli, and quail egg.
What People Love
Theatrical Atmosphere: Reviewers consistently rave about the immersive, high-energy experience — from champagne spectacles to the iconic rhinestone briefcase "Beef Case" presentation, guests describe dinner as a show.
Food Quality: The Wagyu pastrami, truffle corn, and tomahawk steak are repeatedly called out as standouts. Multiple OpenTable diners call it 'the best steak place in the USA' and praise perfectly cooked cuts.
Service: Staff — including servers like Benoît and Ricky — are frequently mentioned by name for attentive, personalized service that elevates special occasions, especially birthdays and anniversaries.
Special Occasions: Papi Steak is a go-to for celebrations; reviewers on multiple platforms describe it as their favorite Miami restaurant for birthdays, Valentine's Day, and milestone dinners.
Frequently Asked Questions
More in South of Fifth
Under the Mango Tree
9.2
Vegan$South of Fifth
Bohemian vegan café in South Beach serving açaí bowls, fresh juices, and superfood goodness
Abbalé Modern Mediterranean Kitchen - South Beach
8.8
Mediterranean$$$South of Fifth
Tel Aviv meets South Beach — modern Mediterranean cuisine with Israeli soul in South of Fifth
Local House
8.6
Seafood$$South of Fifth
Legendary Lobster Eggs Benedict and coastal brunch right on Ocean Drive in South of Fifth
Azabu Miami Beach
8.5
Japanese$$$$South of Fifth
Tokyo-trained sushi chefs, Japan-flown fish, and a Michelin-recognized hidden Den on Ocean Drive
Stubborn Seed - Miami Beach
8.5
American$$$$South of Fifth
Michelin-starred tasting menus by Top Chef winner Jeremy Ford in South of Fifth
Joe's Stone Crab
8.5
Seafood$$$$South of Fifth
Miami Beach's legendary stone crab institution since 1913 — a must-do for every visitor
Listing details verified March 2026.Report a closure or change