Lucali

Lucali brings the legendary Brooklyn pizzeria experience to Miami Beach's Bayshore neighborhood, earning a coveted Michelin Bib Gourmand designation along the way. Housed inside The Bay Club at 1930 Bay Rd, this rustic yet stylish eatery channels charming old-world character through plank floors, chunky tables, and a wood-fired brick oven as the centerpiece.

The menu is refreshingly focused: the 18-inch signature plain pie ($30) arrives lusciously charred with a light, airy crust, fresh pomodoro sauce, a blend of cheeses, and fragrant basil. Customize with premium toppings like imported Italian artichoke hearts, meatball crumbles, or beef pepperoni.

Beyond pizza, standout starters include meatballs ($22), eggplant parm ($21), baked artichokes ($18), and a crisp kale caesar ($16). The calzones and Nutella pie dessert are crowd favorites.

Priced in the $30–50 range per person, Lucali offers genuine quality and value in a family-friendly, LGBTQ+-welcoming atmosphere complete with outdoor seating and a full bar. Walk-ins only — and yes, there's usually a wait, but it's worth every minute.